ppint. ● 9th Dec 2017
| | Rated 4/10immensely successful, commercially, but somewhat dissatisfying sub-tolkienian pentalogy; the story takes a pretty boring and unobservant farm-boy through perilous adventures towards a climactic battle, picking up more or less-unlikely companions as he goes. some of these companions are people he's previously known as pretty ordinary, commonplace adults, unaware of (i.e. never noticing) their extraordinary powers (did i mention his uninquisitive, unobservant nature?); one is an extremely annoying "princess" of a teenager (who actually is a princess), that's somehow managed to avoid being murdered for her whiny, totally self-absorbed selfishness, and another is "silk", a double-dealing, treacherous-but-lovable rogue. . .
that they eventually reach a successful conclusion to their adventures is, of course, inevitable - despite the existence of competing prophecies, or possibly competing interpretations of the same prophecy; and that the princess will prove to be a peach is predictable, if her survival unmurdered by any one of her companions - or the people they meet - was less so; but garion the stableboy - ok, farm boy - is so unimaginably boringly uninterested in the world, his companions, an enchanted sword... - not even his discovery that he's been raised by, and guarded by, two of the most powerful beings in creation suffices to raise a spark of suspicion that there might just possibly be something special about himself. . .
and it's such a waste. the five books are at least competently well written, and there was a brilliant story just waiting to be told: lester del rey° shouldn't have accepted and published this first novel at all; he should've paid the minimum acceptable advance for the rights, and sent it back to the author saying "you're telling the wrong story; it isn't garion's story of unimaginative and unimagined inevitable success against all the odds at all - it's the amoral, inventive, larcenous and entirely self-interested rogue silk's story about how, despite his best intentions, he got lured into taking dangerous, all-but suicidal risks - to achieve something good, okay, but a venture that held no possible profit for him whatsoever - and he still can't work out how they conned him into doing anything so foolhardy..."
° - eddings' editor
5 people found this review helpful. ✔︎ Helpful Review? |