| Various Artists
Kickin' Country 2
05: Toby Keith - A Little Less Talk And A Lot More Action
| | Sony Music Direct Canada | TVK 24013 | 1994 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Fifty Years Of Country Music From Mercury: 1945–1995
3-20: Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy
| | Mercury Nashville USA | 314 526 691-2 | 1995 | CD Box Set | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Country Love
1-14: Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy
| | Heartland Music USA | 3493-2 | 1995 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Music City Now Vol. I
15: Toby Keith - Upstairs Downtown
| | Country Music Association USA | MCN 95-1 | 1995 | Promo Only | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Music City Now Vol. III
14: Toby Keith - Santa I'm Right Here
| | Country Music Association USA | MCN 95-3 | 1995 | Promo Only | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
New Country: Holiday Special 1995
02: Toby Keith - All I Want For Christmas
| | New Country USA | NCWN95D | 1995 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Beach Boys
Stars And Stripes Vol. 1
06: The Beach Boys, Toby Keith - Be True To Your School
| | River North USA | 51416 1205 2 | 20 Aug 1996 | CD Album | 2 | | |
| Various Artists
New Country: Volume 4, Number 12
02: Toby Keith - Jacky Don't Tucker (Play By The Rules Miss All The Fun)
| | New Country USA | | 1997 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Country Christmas
10: Toby Keith - Christmas To Christmas
| | Spectrum Music Europe | 554 242-2 | 1997 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Country Roads (20 Classic Country Songs)
16: Toby Keith - Me Too
| | Marks & Spencer UK | CMD025 | 1997 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
NFS Country Singles For Radio 55
10: Toby Keith - How Do You Like Me Now?!
| | NFS Australia | NFS-CD 55 | Dec 1999 | Promo Only | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
A Country Superstar Christmas 4
02: Toby Keith - Blame It On The Mistletoe
| | Hip-O USA | 314 585 087-2 | 2001 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Travelin' Crossroads: Music From Then And Now
10: Toby Keith - Dream Walkin'
| | Universal Music Special Markets USA | 314 585 827-2 | 2001 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Willie Nelson
Stars & Guitars [Live]
02: Willie Nelson, Toby Keith - Good Hearted Woman
| | Lost Highway Canada | 0881703402 | 2002 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Willie Nelson And Friends
Stars & Guitars
02: Willie Nelson, Toby Keith - Good Hearted Woman
| | Lost Highway USA | 088 170 340-2 | 5 Nov 2002 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Willie Nelson And Friends
Stars & Guitars [Live]
02: Willie Nelson, Toby Keith - Good Hearted Woman
| | Lost Highway Europe | 170 340-2 | 11 Nov 2002 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Classic Country New Frontiers
Disc 1 1-01: Toby Keith - How Do You Like Me Now?
| | Time-Life Music Europe | TL 626/38 | 2003 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| Willie Nelson And Friends
Live And Kickin'
05: Willie Nelson, Toby Keith - Beer For My Horses
| | Lost Highway Europe | 0008817038629 | 21 Jul 2003 | CD Album | 1 | | |
| Willie Nelson
Outlaws And Angels
01: Willie Nelson, Toby Keith, Joe Walsh - Georgia On A Fast Train 02: Willie Nelson, Toby Keith, Joe Walsh, Merle Haggard - Ramblin' Fever
| | Lost Highway Canada | B000279402 | 2004 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Classic Country 1997 - 2000
1-04: Toby Keith - Me Too
| | Time-Life Music Europe | TL 626/40 | 2004 | Double CD | 1 | | |
| Jimmy Buffett
License To Chill
05: Jimmy Buffett With Toby Keith - Piece Of Work
| | Mainboat USA | MBD 2009 | 13 Jul 2004 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Country Legends
01: Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy
| | Madacy USA | B0002263-02 | 2005 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Jerry Lee Lewis
Last Man Standing - The Duets
15: Jerry Lee Lewis, Toby Keith - Ol' Glory
| | Artists First USA | AFT-20001-2 | 2006 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Jerry Lee Lewis
Last Man Standing - The Duets
15: Jerry Lee Lewis, Toby Keith - Ol' Glory
| | Artful UK | ARTFULCD55 | 2006 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Jerry Lee Lewis
Last Man Standing - The Duets
15: Jerry Lee Lewis, Toby Keith - Ol' Glory
| | Go! Entertainment Netherlands | GO70321 | 2006 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Mo's Songs! (7-CD Dreamworks Version)
7-07: Toby Keith - How Do You Like Me Now?
| | Warner Bros. USA | PRO-MO-2006 | 2006 | Multi-Disc | 0 | | |
| Jerry Lee Lewis
Last Man Standing - The Duets
15: Jerry Lee Lewis, Toby Keith - Ol' Glory
| | Edel Germany | 0176682ERE | 11 Oct 2006 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Willie Nelson
Lost Highway
08: Willie Nelson, Toby Keith - Beer For My Horses
| | Lost Highway Europe | 0602527139319 | 11 Aug 2009 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Now That's What I Call Christmas Vol. 4
1-09: Toby Keith - Rockin' Around The Christmas Tree
| | EMI USA | 509996 09848 2 1 | 2010 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
My Country - The Greatest Country Music On The Planet Vol 1
1-08: Toby Keith - Should've Been A Cowboy
| | Rhino Sweden | 5051865-8814-2-1 | 15 May 2010 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
46th Academy Of Country Music Awards Spotlight
1-02: Toby Keith - Somewhere Else
| | 'ZinePak USA | | 2011 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Now That's What I Call Music 41
16: Toby Keith - Red Solo Cup
| | EMI USA | 509990 95758 20 | 2012 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
Country Greats
2-05: Toby Keith - Courtesy Of The Red, White And Blue
| | UMC UK | ULTIM5CD010 | 2017 | Multi-Disc | 1 | | |