A Christmas Carol [1910]

Format:	Short
Year:	1910
Country:	USA
Language:	English
Genre:	Fantasy, Drama
IMDB:	IMDB Page
Rating:	7.0 Rate
Collection:	Seen It Wishlist
Community:	3 Have Seen


Director	J. Searle Dawley
	Charles Kent
	Ashley Miller
Selected Cast	Marc McDermott as Scrooge
	Charles Ogle as Bob Cratchit

Comments and Reviews


Monolith 21st Jun 2015		Thanks for the vid, but i always found this version too wordy for my liking. :grin:



Graham7 21st Jun 2015		Yes, that's why I renamed the 2011 version of Arthur, and created a corresponding cinema entry. so there'd be something to link to. Which is why I would encourage finding, or adding, the appropriate film or TV series when adding a new dvd. I always try to. If you see wrong linkage, please submit a correction. Here's a 2010 remastered version with added music: "Academic Festival Overture, Op. 80" by Concertgebouw Orchestra of Amsterdam.



Monolith 21st Jun 2015		That's true Graham, but that very film showed up here the other day as the "Brand" DVD and listed the "Moore" cast list which is why the Brand one now has the date in the title. The Winslow Boy has been done a couple of times, also Inherit The Wind, 12 Angry Men, Conan The Barbarian, 39 Steps.



Graham7 21st Jun 2015		Wikipedia has a list of some of the films made with this title. Scrooge is also a popular movie title, Dickens' story has been made countless times for TV. This is probably a special case, most film titles are unique. Where there is a potential for confusion, the best known version should be entered without extra identifier, other films with a date disambiguation in [square brackets]. As an example, if I asked who played Arthur in the film of the same name (tt0082031), not many would say Russell Brand (tt1334512) I'd wager.



Twistin 21st Jun 2015		Maybe it would be better to find a way to use the IMDb ID field for DVD linking rather than the title field? That way, the title field can render the title(s) proper.



Monolith 21st Jun 2015		I've seen this a few times now, one film mistakenly being associated with another with the same title. Maybe a guideline would be to include the year with the title as standard if that's possible. Can the database handle an automatic thing like that?



Graham7 21st Jun 2015		I've renamed this short film, with [1910] appended to the title. So it's no longer linked to the 1984 George C. Scott version DVD.



Twistin 21st Jun 2015		The DVD linked here is definitely not the same "A Christmas Carol" as this 1910 silent short.

Add a Comment or Review about this movie

Tags: Christmas Film

This Movie: Add Image : Add Video : Add Missing Info : Make Correction : Add to List : Add See Also : Add Tag : Edit Images : Show Image Data : Credits : BBCode