Occasionally we see the comment, Edit This Image under uploads. Sometimes the reasons are obvious, such as not being circle cropped. At other times, the reasons seem bizarre.
Which leads me to this, one of my own uploads. Can any moderator please explain why these labels need editing?
Crates Are For Digging Member since Aug 2012 25120 Points Moderator
Having looked at the images as the one who skipped them the A side seems spot on the B side seems to be not quite straight. As we deal with thousands of images errors may occur but putting it in the edit queue just means someone else will look at it and either edit or leave as is. It is nothing to worry about and if one is missed that needs editing than a Mod. can edit it if required.
No picture 'cos I'm not into 45rpm :( Member since Jan 2013 3379 Points Moderator
As I say in the image editing tutorial, most moderators are extremely fussy when assessing images .
In the entry you linked to (https://www.45worlds.com/vinyl/album/playlp10), all the images have been accepted except the last two showing the record labels. I'd suggest that both these images have not been accepted because they show a small amount of run out in black surrounding the label. Moderators expect label images to be tightly cropped so no run out shows. The Side 2 label also needs a bit of rotation to get the text horizontal.
Self praise is no recommendation. Member since Oct 2011 44927 Points Moderator
I'm afraid that I'm one of the 'extremely fussy' moderators that scrough refers to. I like my label images to be straightly aligned and precisely cropped to fully fit the page (and preferably with no black vinyl showing - unless it is a white label).