Selected Cast | Brian Gerard |
| Meghan Reilly |
| Shane Booth |
| Courtney Schlagel |
| Shastin Corona as Season 1 |
| Kirstin Highfield as Season 1 |
| Jessica Pleyel as Season 1 |
| Jennifer Grannis as Season 1 |
| Janis Babcock as Season 1 |
| Guy Clark as Season 1 |
| Greg Magnuson as Season 1 |
| Eric Chellen as Season 1 |
| Brett Ratell as Season 1 |
| Walter E. Beck as Season 2 |
| Karen G. Peterson French as Season 2 |
| Thure Gustafsson as Season 2. 2012 |
| Vernon Neil Ferguson as Season 2. 2012 |
| Travis Scott McAfee as Season 2. 2012 |
| Anna Ostman Mohr as Season 2. 2012 Winner |
| Megan Reilly as Season 2. 2012 |
| Matthew Lidfors Robinson as Season 2. 2012 |
| Debra Sisneros Sutherland as Season 2. 2012 |
| Kelsey Stiles as Season 2. 2012 |
| Rebecca Redner as Season 3. 2013 |
| Dianne Bennett as Season 3. 2013 |
| Laura McIntyre as Season 3. 2013 |
| Lori Ferguson as Season 3. 2013 Winner |
| Dawn Anderson as Season 3. 2013 |
| Eric Basir as Season 3. 2013 |
| Matthew Anderson as Season 3. 2013 |
| Michael Peterson as Season 3. 2013 |
| John Stenson as Season 3. 2013 |
| Shanne Booth as Season 3. 2013 |
| Jennette Landes as Season 4. 2014 |
| John Olson as Season 4. 2014 Winner |
| Nicolas "Nick" Jones as Season 4. 2014 |
| Amanda Vinicky as Season 4. 2014 |
| Courtney Schlagell as Season 4. 2014 |
| George Strid as Season 4. 2014 |
| Katie Malik as Season 4. 2014 |
| Nate Butler as Season 4. 2014 |
| Troy Bankord as Season 4. 2014 |
| Leslie Longoria as Season 4. 2014 |
| Alexis Bunten as Season 5. 2015 |
| Nathan Arling as Season 5. 2015 |
| Kurt Engstrom as Season 5. 2015 |
| Charles Wassberg as Season 5. 2015 |
| Beverly Wassberg as Season 5. 2015 |
| Karen Berg-Roylance as Season 5. 2015 |
| Jamie Lystra as Season 5. 2015 |
| John Winscher as Season 5. 2015 Winner |
| Brooke Langton as Season 5. 2015 |
| James Morgan as Season 5. 2015 |
| Jenna Wroblewski as Season 5. 2015 |
| John Burt as Season 6. 2016 |
| Inger Romero as Season 6. 2016 |
| Erica Andersson as Season 6. 2016 |
| Erik "Swede" Seaholm as Season 6. 2016 |
| Jason Blohm as Season 6. 2016 |
| Anna Lopinto as Season 6. 2016 |
| Patrick Glass as Season 6. 2016 |
| Steven Swanson as Season 6. 2016 |
| Micka Cain as Season 6. 2016 |
| Sarah Steinman as Season 6. 2016 Winner |
| Alexander Kronholm as Season 7. 2017 |
| Ann Oswald as Season 7. 2017 |
| Cosondra Sjostrom as Season 7. 2017 |
| Amanda Orozco as Season 7. 2017 |
| Kristin Lancione as Season 7. 2017 |
| Victoria "Tori" Milar as Season 7. 2017 |
| Dylan Ratell as Season 7. 2017 |
| Jack Waters as Season 7. 2017 |
| Nathan Younggren as Season 7. 2017 |
| Kurt Carlson as Season 7. 2017 |
| Kyle Johnson as Season 8. 2018 Winner |
| Kevin Chown as Season 8. 2018 |
| Tanya Edgil as Season 8. 2018 |
| Domonique Jackson-Russel as Season 8. 2018 |
| Louis Larsson as Season 8. 2018 |
| Andrew Morrison as Season 8. 2018 |
| Ashley Mullinax as Season 8. 2018 |
| David Neslund as Season 8. 2018 |
| Susan "Susy" Snyder as Season 8. 2018 |
| Christina Wight as Season 8. 2018 |
| Jennifer Buhrow as Season 9. 2019 Winner |
| Janet ”Holgie” Caplinger as Season 9. 2019 |
| Kaytie Hubis as Season 9. 2019 |
| Robert Rambo as Season 9. 2019 |
| Roy ”Dude” Settergren III as Season 9. 2019 |
| Christina Sittser, as Season 9. 2019 |
| Christopher Tholstrom as Season 9. 2019 |
| Mats Thureson as Season 9. 2019 |
| Melissa Walls as Season 9. 2019 |
| Brittany "Britt" Zikman as Season 9. 2019 |
| Erika Newell as Season 10, 2022 Winner |
| Sharon Fabriz as Season 10, 2022 |
| Sally Fransson as Season 10, 2022 |
| Brett Gross as Season 10, 2022 |
| Trevor Ohlsen as Season 10, 2022 |
| Michael Palmer as Season 10, 2022 |
| Brittany Pearson as Season 10, 2022 |
| Jon Strand as Season 10, 2022 |
| Melody Sky Weaver, as Season 10, 2022 |
| Nicole Archer as Season 10, 2022 |