|
Beggars Road 16th Nov 2017
| | Submitted 'Make Correction' to delete the secondary cat #, BMG15025, for this entry! |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 16th Nov 2017
| | @to all: The wise and powerful Oz of Admin (Dr Doom) has spoken.
Also, a shout out to Magic Marmalade for the help - thanks M squared. |
|
|
|
Jasper 15th Nov 2017
| | Is the secondary (BMG) cat # relevant on this entry? |
|
|
|
Magic Marmalade 15th Nov 2017
| | US issue entry currently under construction.
[All done, and linked below] |
|
|
|
Dr Doom SUBS 15th Nov 2017
| | I'd say that the US issue warrants a page of it's own due to the alternate catalogue number and barcode |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 15th Nov 2017
| | My Lord or My Lady, Beggars Road rests! |
|
|
|
Lee Wrecker🍰 ● 14th Nov 2017
| | The USA copy images here from Beggars Road indicate that the USA version should be a separate release as indicated in the comments by PhilMH. In line with Phil I also think a new entry is required. |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 14th Nov 2017
| | Simple or sophism?
If International were not an option I would agree with you but as I commented on previously I believe that is precisely why Admin added this Country of Origin category. |
|
|
|
PhilMH 14th Nov 2017
| | From the guide to adding CD's:
"Generally, there is a single page for each CD product/barcode. Please search for the barcode to ensure your CD is not already on 45worlds."
Barcodes are not irrelevant on this site at all. That, plus the fact that the catalogue number is also completely different - BMG15025 as opposed to 1797062 - means that the US copy needs a separate entry. If the US copy had identical cat no and barcode, then it could stay on this entry, but it doesn't, it's that simple. |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 13th Nov 2017
| | UPC/barcodes are irrelevant - they are used for selling a product e.g. Record Club issues sans UPC/barcodes.
Quote:"...if the US disc uses same mastering and same packaging (adjusted for US distribution details),..."
I believe this is why Dr. Doom instituted the "International" Country category.
I simply added the USA variant of the same entry. |
|
|
|
PhilMH 12th Nov 2017
| | Even if the US disc uses same mastering and same packaging (adjusted for US distribution details), a completely different catalogue number plus completely different barcode means that it needs a completely separate entry. International is only used if (a) the same pressing with exactly the same catalogue number and barcode details is distributed by the record company's subsidiaries or licensees in different countries, or (b) (and there has been much debate about this) pressings in other countries use the same catalogue number and barcode. The US copy here fails on both of those tests. |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 12th Nov 2017
| | @PhilMH: We certainly have a different perspective about CD's, especially when it comes to mastering.
See image 1497919 - mastering info.
IMHO: For all intents and purposes it's the same. |
|
|
|
PhilMH 11th Nov 2017
| | The US issue has a different catalogue number, BMG15025, plus a different barcode, and would also have been issued later than 2009, because BMG didn't acquire Sanctuary/Trojan until 2013, when it was sold by Universal (who issued the UK version of this collection in 2009) as one of the European Commission's conditions for buying most of EMI. So, US pressing needs its own entry. |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 11th Nov 2017
| | This is the same issue and should be changed to 'International'. |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 11th Nov 2017
| | Matrix/runout:
Disc 1: 03/24/2015 11:41:09 AM IFPI LN08 270367 01 JI05
Disc 2: 03/23/2015 12:27:00.00#40632 IFPI LN09 270368 01 JI02
Double digipak fold-out with 28 page booklet USA issue. |
|
|
|
Beggars Road 11th Nov 2017
| | Added USA Trojan BMG release scan(s). |
|
|