| The Everly Brothers
The Collection
15: Should We Tell Him
| | Castle Communications UK | CCSCD 139 | May 1986 | CD Album | 0 | 8.1 | |
| The Everly Brothers
Greatest Recordings
13: Should We Tell Him
| | Ace UK | CDCH 903 | May 1986 | CD Album | 4 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
All They Had To Do Was Dream
14: Should We Tell Him
| | Rhino USA | R2 70214 | 1988 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Very Best Of The Everly Brothers
03: Should We Tell Him
| | Pickwick UK | PWKS 515 | Oct 1988 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Ebony Eyes And Other Great Songs
10: Should We Tell Him
| | CéDé International Europe | CD 66110 | 1989 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers' Best Vol. 1
11: Should We Tell Him
| | Cadence Japan | 25CP-48 | 21 Apr 1989 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers / The Fabulous Style Of The Everly Brothers
12: Should We Tell Him
| | Ace UK | CDCH 932 | 1990 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| Everly Brothers
Classic Everly Brothers
1-12: Should We Tell Him 1-07: Should We Tell Him
| | Bear Family Germany | BCD 15618 | 1992 | CD Box Set | 1 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Bye Bye Love, The Everly Brothers Greatest Hits
11: Should We Tell Him
| | Companion Europe | 6188452 | 1993 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Original British Hit Singles
05: Should We Tell Him
| | Ace UK | CDCHM 544 | 5 Dec 1994 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Very Best Of The Everly Brothers
13: Should We Tell Him
| | Crimson UK | CRIMCD65 | 21 May 1997 | CD Album | 2 | 7.4 | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Very Best Of The Cadence Era
10: Should We Tell Him
| | Repertoire Germany | REP 4829-WG | 1999 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Complete Cadence Recordings 1957-1960
1-05: Should We Tell Him 1-10: Should We Tell Him
| | Varèse Sarabande USA | 302 066 217 2 | 3 Apr 2001 | Double CD | 1 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Too Good To Be True
06: Should We Tell Him
| | Varèse Sarabande USA | 302 066 641 2 | 2005 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Bye Bye Love
1-08: Should We Tell Him
| | Foreign Media Netherlands | 8242 | 2006 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers
2-05: Should We Tell Him
| | Hallmark UK | 720402 | 2006 | CD Box Set | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
They`re Off And Rolling
11: Should We Tell Him
| | Ace UK | CDCHM 1127 | Aug 2006 | CD Album | 1 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Bye Bye Love
07: Should We Tell Him
| | Magic France | 3930805 | 2008 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
100 Hits - Legends
1-05: Should We Tell Him
| | 100 Hits UK | LEGENDS019 | 5 Jul 2010 | Multi-Disc | 1 | | |
| Various Artists
The London American Story - 1958
1-04: Should We Tell Him
| | One Day Music UK | DAY2CD128 | 2011 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers + It`s Everly Time
11: Should We Tell Him
| | Hoodoo Europe | 263400 | 2011 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Essential Everly Brothers
1-11: Should We Tell Him
| | Not Now Music UK | NOT2CD394 | Feb 2011 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Very Best Of The Everly Brothers
2-16: Should We Tell Him
| | Union Square UK | USMMDCD 005 | 2012 | Double CD | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers
1-11: Should We Tell Him
| | Real Gone UK | RGMCD022 | 29 Jun 2012 | CD Box Set | 1 | | |
| Various Artists
The Forgotten 45s 1957-1959
2-20: Should We Tell Him
| | Fantastic Voyage UK | FVTD158 | 2013 | Multi-Disc | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Rock
02: Should We Tell Him
| | Bear Family Germany | BCD 17321 AR | Feb 2013 | CD Album | 2 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers
1-07: Should We Tell Him
| | Magic France | 3930983 | 2014 | Double CD | 1 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Rock And Roll
04: Should We Tell Him
| | Rock Beat USA | ROC-3287 | 2014 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Walk Right Back - The Singles Collection 1956-1962
1-08: Should We Tell Him
| | Jasmine UK | JASCD 792 | 2016 | CD Album | 1 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Five Classic Albums Plus Bonus Singles & Radio Show Tracks
1-11: Should We Tell Him
| | Reel To Reel Europe | RTRCD16 | 2018 | Multi-Disc | 0 | | |
| Various Artists
The Ten Commandments Of Rock 'N' Roll - Nine "Fend Off Impassiveness" (Lonesome For A Letter)
18: Should We Tell Him
| | Atomicat Europe | ACCD 058 | Oct 2021 | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
All I Have To Do Is Dream
1-07: Should We Tell Him
| | Documents Europe | 233224 | | CD Box Set | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers
11: Should We Tell Him
| | Fox Music Unknown Country | FU 1100 | | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
The Everly Brothers
10: Should We Tell Him
| | Music Ages Spain | 34090 | | CD Album | 0 | | |
| The Everly Brothers
Love Songs
05: Should We Tell Him
| | Success Europe | 2208CD | | CD Album | 0 | | |