![](//images.45worlds.com/t/ab/the-wailers-catch-a-fire-11-ab-t.jpg)
Comment by Fokeman:
My review was just my personal experience of listening to this historical recording and enjoying it. It wasn't a PHD thesis. Why not write your own review instead of picking holes in my review?
Comment by Upsetter FC:
Your review seemed detached from the Wailers history. As your examples of what ifs of rock musicians show, your perspective is not of the Wailers as Jamaican musicians. Jamaican music did not work like the US/UK music industry.
And staying in Jamaica was not going to change the fact that Bob's ability as a songwriter was pulling him away from the other Wailers. This LP just accelerated the changes already happening in the partnership that was the Wailers.
Comment by Fokeman:
Upsetter FC. Yes, I know all that you have said. I'm trying to work out why you would assume that I didn't know that they had been together as the Wailers in Jamaica prior to this album? Was it the way I used already? You have managed to make judgments on history that are always dodgy. "they did not survive the fame..." which suggests everyone would be better off had they stayed in Jamaica and never found international fame. It may be true but the world isn't made of ifs. Bon Scott, Keith Moon, John Bonham might all be alive, if...
Stir It Up wasn't written by Bob Marley, unlike most of his hits but why did you assume I didn't know that? I certainly didn't suggest that it was new or written by him. Just done brilliantly here by the band.