Ok, Charlie 45 ... Time for an update! The "target" label with the odd cat# is... Drum roll please.. a Capitol record club pressing from 1968.. these were contract pressings, and in fact, just may have been pressed by MCA at Pinkneyville, if there is a hand written "2" in the deadwax.
I've also seen a copy with a yellow variation of Capitol's infamous orange label, cat# SM-357, with no mention of it being part of the Star Line. This was from 1972.
This one confuses me a little because I have both these copies and the Title and the song tracks are identical but the Cat # on the second Starline is the same as a different version (of Unforgettable) with different tracks. Was there some kind of label mistake here, or what?
I don't understand why there is 2 different listings for Nat King Cole and Nat "King" Cole. Because I put Nat "King" Cole the Album went to another listing, yet one of the records on the Nate King Cole site is still listed as Nat "King" Cole. Do some make it to the other site and some don't???? Can we at least link them?